Entries from February 1, 2009 - February 28, 2009

Thursday
Feb122009

The Flight of a Falcon

An oblique view of the flight-track of a peregrine falcon taken from the paper "Comparing bird and human soaring strategies" by Zsuzsa Akos, Mate Nagy, and Tamas Vicsek (Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 105, 4139-4143, 2008.  arXiv:0902.0312v1 [physics.bio-ph]).  The altitude and location of the bird were tracked by fitting it with a miniaturized GPS device.  The red and yellow parts of the track correspond to when the bird was climbing (mostly on thermals), and the blue parts to when the bird was falling (gliding).  The grey background is a satellite image of the terrain.

Saturday
Feb072009

Dead Fox

A dead fox at the eastern edge of the large lake, Reading University grounds, Reading, UK.  The local lakes have been mostly covered by ice for the past few days. It could be that the fox ventured out on the ice at night but fell through into the icy-cold water and couldn't get out again.  Photo taken on 2009-02-07.

Thursday
Feb052009

The Vortex Theory of the Atom

From a review by Martin Gardner of Lee Smolin's and Peter Woit's books attacking String Theory:

In the nineteenth century, a conjecture called the vortex theory of the atom became extremely popular in England and America. Proposed by the famous British physicist Lord Kelvin, it had an uncanny resemblance to string theory. It was widely believed at the time that space was permeated by an in- compressible frictionless fluid called the ether. Atoms, Kelvin suggested, are super-small whirlpools of ether, vaguely similar to smoke rings. They take the form of knots and links. Point particles can’t vibrate. Ether rings can. Their shapes and frequencies determine all the properties of the elements. Vortex theory isn’t mentioned by Woit, although Smolin considers it briefly.

Kelvin published two books defending his conjecture. It was strongly championed in England by J. J. Thomson in his 1907 book The Corpuscular Theory of Matter. Another booster of the theory was Peter Tait, an Irish mathematician. His work, like Witten’s, led to significant advances in knot theory. In the United States, Albert Michelson considered vortex theory so “grand” that “it ought to be true even if it is not.” Hundreds of papers elaborated the theory. Tait predicted it would take generations to develop its elegant mathematics. Alas, beautiful though vortex theory was, it proved to be a glorious road that led nowhere.

I first read about the importance of the vortex theory to the development of knot theory in The Knot Book by Colin Adams.

Page 1 2