« Possible Mouse-Wheel Scroll Bug in Windows XP | Main | Intellectual Bookshop »

Search Engine 'Cloaking' by Academic Publishers

One of the minor annoyances of using Google to search for scientific papers is the habit of some academic publishers of 'cloaking' their PDF files.  This means that in the search results these files are listed as if they were freely accessible but when you click through you immediately go to a page demanding payment.  You are not even presented with an abstract of the paper so you can judge whether or not you might be interested in its contents.  I would have normally expected Google to have removed such cloaked PDFs from their search results, but it seems as if they have made some deal with the publishers which allows this to continue in return for access to the publisher's papers.  It all seems a bit clumsily done and smacks of deception and spamming.

Well it seems that quite a few proper scientists are sufficiently annoyed by this cloaking to discuss doing something about it.  See The n-Category Cafe, BlogSci, and Science After Sunclipse for more details.

Reader Comments (1)

I don't mind that too much, because it, in a sense, works like a literature search. If I don't have access to a particular journal from my personal computer, I copy the citation and later look it up in a library or download it from a library computer.
August 13 | Unregistered CommenterAydin

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.