« Evaporative Cooling of Group Beliefs | Main | Bud »

Mistakes as Spurs to Research

Here are a couple of examples in which young researchers submitted papers for publication which contained potentially embarrassing mistakes.  But, rather than being put off by their mistakes and retiring into obscurity to to lick their wounds, both researchers were spurred into doing the work which made them famous.

From this biography of the mathematician Neils Henrik Abel:

While in his final year at school, however, Abel had begun working on the solution of quintic equations by radicals. He believed that he had solved the quintic in 1821 and submitted a paper to the Danish mathematician Ferdinand Degen, for publication by the Royal Society of Copenhagen.  Degen asked Abel to give a numerical example of his method and, while trying to provide an example, Abel discovered the mistake in his paper.

Abel went on to prove that there is no general solution in radicals to quintic equations (the Abel-Ruffini theorem). In his book Finding Moonshine, Marcus du Sautoy suggests that Degen actually recognised that Abel's solution was flawed and, by asking for a numerical example, he was gently prompting Abel to look at his work again, without discouraging him.

The second example is from here on the web-site of the computer scientist Leslie Lamport:

When I first learned about the mutual exclusion problem, it seemed easy and the published algorithms seemed needlessly complicated.  So, I dashed off a simple algorithm and submitted it to CACM. I soon received a referee's report pointing out the error.  This had two effects. First, it made me mad enough at myself to sit down and come up with a real solution.  The result was the bakery algorithm described in.  The second effect was to arouse my interest in verifying concurrent algorithms.

Lamport's bakery algorithm was just the first of many important contributions he made in the field of concurrent algorithms.

Reader Comments (1)

I was going to post a comment, but then decided to write a post about this on my blog & include a link to your post.
March 22 | Unregistered CommenterAydin

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.